One of the biggest mistakes new podcast hosts make is jumping into the world of audio content with a script and an agenda, but missing the key element that actually makes podcasts work: authentic conversation.
Take it from the real pros behind Content Monsta’s production desk. Too often, hosts prepare a laundry list of questions, zero in on hitting their talking points, and forget that the real magic happens in the moments between the questions. The best podcasts are not a checklist; they’re a discovery, both for the host and the audience.
Forget the Checklist, Find Curiosity
It all starts with mindset. Are you “being a host,” or are you being yourself? Marc, a Podcast Producer and Interview Coach, offers the secret: stop performing and just start having a real conversation.
Imagine you and your guest are tucked into the corner of a coffee shop, talking over drinks, forgetting the mic is even there. What if your best moments were just naturally recorded and then shared because the exchange held genuine insight and energy? That’s the model you want to chase.
Listen, Learn, Lead: The Three L’s in Action
Podcasting success boils down to three things: Listen, Learn, and Lead.
Listen:
Most podcast hosts focus so much on steering the conversation, they miss its heart. If you’re stuck on your next question, you won’t catch the golden nugget your guest just dropped. Marc’s challenge to every new host is to carry just a handful of questions, highlight the must-asks, and let your curiosity fill in the rest.
Learn:
When you approach each interview ready to learn, not just to perform, you show genuine curiosity. That curiosity leads to better questions in real time, keeps the conversation fresh, and lets the guest’s expertise shine. A. Lee Judge shares his own journey from long, rigid question lists to entering every show with just four dynamic starting points—and finding much richer discussions as a result.
Lead:
Leading is about guiding the conversation with intent, helping your guest shine, and steering the dialogue back on track when it drifts. Hosts think they need to be polite and never interrupt, but great podcasts need curation. If your guest starts to ramble, it’s okay -even necessary – to interject and dig deeper into the moments that matter.
Pre-interviews: Do They Help or Hurt?
Hosts often wonder if they should conduct pre-interviews. The surprising revelation from the Content Monsta team: skip them. When both host and guest already know all the stories, you’re performing instead of discovering. Audiences crave the authenticity of in-the-moment realization, not the replay of a rehearsed script.
Prioritize for Human Connection (Not SEO Checklists)
Getting caught up in content goals – keyword hits, topic coverage, and satisfying your marketing team – can pull you away from what listeners want. The most engaging moments are when the host is curious about the same thing the listener is. Chasing a must-hit list at the expense of dialogue makes your content robotic, and the audience tunes out.
Learning to group related questions, skip redundancies, and seize on the live surprises makes your interviews better, for listeners and for your guests, who feel heard and valued. Plus, when you create those standout moments, you empower your guests to share the content more widely, turning them into advocates who will amplify your reach.
Keep the Conversation in the Listener’s Lane
Tangents can be fun, but context matters. If your show is about marketing, and your guest’s New York vacation comes up, the job of a skilled host is to keep things relevant – to direct curiosity where it serves the audience, not just the ego or curiosity of the host.
Why Interrupting (Politely) is a Superpower
Do not let politeness turn into passivity. If your guest is wandering, step in, acknowledge the value of their comment, and redirect. “That was an amazing point – let’s dig deeper” is both a compliment and a transition. Your audience will thank you for staying focused and keeping the energy high.
Give Your Guests What They Need to Share
The secret weapon for podcast growth is giving guests content they want to share. If you can weave in questions and commentary that help your guests look good, frame their expertise, and offer them quotable moments, you increase the odds they will promote the show to their own audience. That is how you amplify your impact organically.
Podcasting in 2025: Less Performance, More Presence
The bottom line: Your audience is seeking a real conversation, not a performance. Skip the pages of scripts. Go in with a few strategic questions. Be ready to learn, react, and redirect. Interrupt when necessary to go deeper. Guide your guest to memorable moments, and keep everything relevant to your listener.
The three L’s – Listen, Learn, Lead – sound simple, but mastering them is what separates forgettable audio from unforgettable podcasts.
Ready to hit record? Remember: plan less, listen more, and trust your curiosity to guide the way.
Podcast Production Company Owners Talk “Red Flags” for B2B Podcasters
A. Lee Judge and Katie Brinkley talk about what they, as owners of podcast agencies, see when working with companies looking to podcast.
They discuss the “red flags” they look out for when companies approach them about starting a podcast.
How Much Does it Cost to Hire a Podcast Production Company?
A quick breakdown of what it should cost to hire a podcast production company to help you with your podcast production and promotion.
Design That Drives Action: Jim MacLeod on the Real Job of Visual Marketing
Jim MacLeod, author of The Visual Marketer, shares how design shapes marketing outcomes, the psychology behind effective visuals, and why marketers must learn the science of visual communication to stay competitive.
